
As a British Rugby League fan, and one who is far more concerned about the game as a whole rather than my own solitary club, I should be ecstatic at the fact that we’ve won our first test series since 1993 by beating New Zealand 3-0 over these last few weeks and, in some ways, I am – but I’m not so ecstatic about how some people are getting ridiculously carried away by the whole thing.
Maybe it’s just a reaction to being success-starved for so long, and people just want something they can crow about but, if you scratch beneath the surface a little I’d say there isn’t too much to get excited about just yet.
New GB coach Tony Smith is being hailed as some kind of coaching genius for inspiring the series win, yet in the 5 previous tests on home soil against this opposition GB have won 4 of them, so it’s not exactly out of the blue that we’ve been able to defeat them so convincingly, and that’s before getting started on the “strength” of the side that was sent over.
The Kiwis always seem to have problems of one kind or another when trying to put an international outfit together, suffering from multiple withdrawals and clubs not wanting to release players, and they were further hampered this time out by the retirements of two true Kiwi RL legends in Ruben Wiki and Stacey Jones, the sides biggest two players and leaders over the last few years, and it has shown on the pitch – not only over here, but before that when they were thrashed 58-0 by Australia, who were missing one or two of their top stars themselves. This year they have also been hit by the departure of coach Brian McClennan, with the inexperienced Gary Kemble having to come in and try and pick up the pieces.
Another thing that has to be questioned is the commitment of some players to the Kiwi cause, we’ve seen players unwilling to battle their clubs to be allowed to play in test matches in the past and, with the world cup coming up next year, we’ve now got a succession of players who have played for the Kiwis deciding that they actually want to play for Samoa, where they have roots either themeslves, or through family, though I wonder if that will change if Samoa don’t qualify, no doubt it will and the likes of David Solomona will come crawling back, but you can hardly expect such players to be relied upon when they are willing to chop and change their loyalties every other year.
It was a real boost for the game when the Kiwis defeated the Australians to win the tri-nations back in 2005, but it’s all been downhill from there with only 2 wins in 13 tests subsequently for the sake of themselves, and for international RL hopefully they’ll be able to get themselves back on track in time to ensure next years World Cup is truly competitive.
Although the Kiwis were bad GB can obviously take some positives and, if nothing else, our players should now have a bit more confidence after experiencing success on the international stage but the brigade saying “now bring on the Aussies”, “Tony Smith is an international coaching guru” and “Rob Burrow is the scrum half we’ve been lacking for 20 years, if only he’d been playing against the Aussies these last few years” are obviously a lot easier to convince than I am. Let’s see how a half-back pairing of Rob Burrow and Leon Pryce cope with the Australians, when they won’t be playing with the momentum GB have been able to build against this poor Kiwi outfit, let’s see how Jon Clarke does at dummy half in a similar situation, and let’s see how we can respond to letting in soft early tries against them and a stronger Kiwi side before we declare that Tony Smith has turned a team of also rans into world beaters.